Two of the most sought-after countertop materials are quartz and granite. They are both beautiful and can seemingly last forever, but there are some big differences that will determine which one you should go for.
Given how expensive they can get, you’ll want to read on and find out exactly which one you should invest in…
Different Rocks for Different Folks
The choice between quartz and granite ultimately depends on your specific needs, preferences, and the intended use in your home. With many heated debates on the internet around this topic, we want to give you a completely unbiased point of view on the matter.
Both materials have their advantages and considerations. A clear distinction is that while granite comes directly from nature and no two pieces are identical, quartz is a man-made product. Here is a bullet list to give you an idea of the differences between the two materials:
Quartz Countertops
- Appearance: Offers a wide range of colors and patterns with a consistent look.
- Durability: Resistant to stains, scratches, and cracks; non-porous surface.
- Maintenance: Low maintenance, does not require sealing.
- Consistency: More uniform in appearance compared to natural stone.
Granite Countertops
- Appearance: Natural, unique patterns; each slab is one of a kind.
- Durability: Durable and resistant to heat; can withstand heavy use.
- Maintenance: Requires periodic sealing to prevent stains.
- Variety: Wide variety of colors and patterns.
Quartz vs Granite Comparison
While some argue that quartz is better, there are instances in which it won’t work as well as granite. Read on to find out what those instances are…
Appearance of Granite and Quartz
Granite countertops are like snowflakes, no two slabs look the same. They come from pure stone with unique patterns, swirls, and speckles in various colors. Each granite countertop adds a distinct character to your kitchen or outdoor kitchen top.
Quartz countertops offer a more uniform look because they’re engineered stones mixed with resin. Colors and designs stay consistent across pieces, making quartz great for large areas where matching is important.
They shine bright and work well as a stylish backsplash that catches the eye instantly.
Price Differences
Price differences between quartz and granite countertops are a significant consideration for homeowners. Here’s a comparison table to outline the costs you can expect in VA:
| Countertop Material | Average Cost Per Square Foot | Factors Influencing Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Quartz | $60 - $150 | Brand, quality, pattern, and installation complexity |
| Granite | $40 - $100 | Grade of stone, rarity of color, thickness, and installation difficulty |
Prices vary based on several factors, including material grade and intricacy of installation. Expect quartz to generally be priced higher, reflecting its manufacturing process and consistent patterning. Granite’s cost hinges on stone rarity and slab size. When budgeting, include potential extra costs such as edge styles, finish types, and backsplash materials.
Maintenance and Care
Maintaining your countertops keeps them looking great for years. Both quartz and granite require different types of care.
- Wipe quartz counters with mild soap and water to clean spills and crumbs.
- Clean granite surfaces using a special stone cleaner or warm, soapy water to avoid damage.
- Use cutting boards on both types of countertops to prevent scratches.
- Avoid harsh chemicals on quartz as they can harm the surface.
- Seal granite regularly to protect it from stains and moisture.
- Treat spots quickly on both materials to prevent lasting marks.
Lifespan and Repair
Taking good care of your countertops will help them last longer. Quartz and granite floors have long lifespans when maintained properly. Regular cleaning with mild, non-abrasive cleaners is essential to preserve the natural beauty of these surfaces. Avoiding harsh chemicals and abrasive materials helps prevent scratches and maintains the polished finish.
- Quartz is tough, resisting scratches and chips well. It can last for decades without needing repair. Quartz rarely needs repairs. However, if it does break or scratch, fixing it can be tricky because matching the pattern can be challenging. In contrast, granite repairs often blend in naturally with the stone's unique patterns.
- Granite is also strong but may chip or crack more easily than quartz. If granite does get damaged, it's usually possible to fix the chips or cracks. Remember to seal granite once a year to keep it looking great and make it last longer!
Quartz rarely needs repairs, helping you avoid extra costs over time. However, if it does break or scratch, fixing it can be tricky because matching the pattern can be challenging. In contrast, granite repairs often blend in naturally with the stone’s unique patterns.
Remember to seal granite once a year to keep it looking great and make it last longer!
Water and Heat Resistance of Quartz and Granite
Both quartz and granite offer resistance to moisture but differ when exposed to high temperatures. Quartz is non-porous, making it very resistant to water damage and stains.
It stands up well against spills and doesn’t need sealing. Granite, while also resistant to water when sealed properly, can absorb liquids if not maintained.
Earlier on we mentioned that there are some instances in which quartz is not an ideal choice in some instances…and it’s 100% true! You don’t want to place it near a heat source like an open flame for example as it can lead to cracking and permanent damage. While granite is naturally heat resistant, we don’t recommend using it as a place to rest your hot pans either, given its high value.
Homeowners should use trivets or hot pads with quartz to keep their countertops looking great.
- Quartz is non-porous, providing high resistance to water damage and stains without the need for sealing. Vulnerable to cracking and permanent damage when exposed to high temperatures, making it essential to avoid placing it near heat sources like open flames. Trivets or hot pads are recommended to preserve the countertop's appearance.
- Granite is resistant to water when properly sealed, preventing water damage and stains. It is also naturally heat resistant; however, it is not recommended to place hot pans directly on the surface to avoid potential damage.
Quartz vs Granite: Environmental Impact
While considering water and heat resistance, think about what countertops do for the planet. They are by no means eco-friendly materials. However, they are long lasting, meaning they don’t have to be constantly recycled, like plastic chairs.
- Quartz is an engineered stone, which means it mixes natural quartz with resin in a factory. Making quartz countertops can use a lot of energy and produce waste.
- Granite is different because it's pure stone. It gets cut from the earth in big blocks, then sliced into slabs for counters. Digging up granite can hurt nearby land and animals' homes.
Both materials may come from far away, adding to their carbon footprint due to shipping. Using local granite or recycled quartz can lower this impact and help your home be more eco-friendly.
Resale Value
Quartz countertops may boost your home’s value. They are trendy and draw buyers who love their low-maintenance needs. Granite also offers a lasting value that can appeal to those seeking natural stone beauty.
Both materials add charm and could make your home sell faster.
Upgrading to quartz or granite floors before selling your Virginia home might be a smart move. Buyers often look for homes with modern touches like these stone surfaces. Such an investment could increase the overall accessibility of the house to more potential buyers, leading to better resale outcomes.
Remodel Your Kitchen With Whatever Suits Your Needs
If you still can’t decide between granite and quartz, we recommend going to see some samples in person at your local Lowe’s, Home Depot or any home improvement store. Choosing the right one for your needs is ultimately the best choice.
If you want our expert opinion regarding which material works best for your kitchen remodel or need help installing them, reach out to us at (703) 675-7574 or by using the form below.